by Vidhurinda Samaraweera
“Pa pa pa Paaa…. Pa pa pa Paaa” (pause).
I am certain that anyone reading this article will instantly recognize the motif illustrated. Yes, it is the opening of Beethoven’s well-known Fifth Symphony. This landmark work is likely being performed at multiple locations around the world as you are reading this or is, at least, programmed for an upcoming concert. Be that as it may, the last time Beethoven’s Fifth was performed in Sri Lanka was approximately 12 years ago by the Symphony Orchestra of Sri Lanka (SOSL) under the direction of German conductor, Dr. Hans Nagel. Unfortunately, the concert was not a success as had been hoped. Dry acoustics in the newly built concert hall and the technical inadequacies of some sections were likely contributing reasons. I was contracted to fill in as second horn for the performance as a young 14-year-old. Of course, I had an older player on first to guide me, someone who had played the symphony multiple times during his tenure.
Although Beethoven’s Fifth is considered a staple in an orchestral musician’s extensive repertoire, one would be surprised to learn that it is not frequently performed in Sri Lanka—or in this part of the world. Even though I have orchestral experience, having performed on the island for over 14 years, the 2024/25 Season opening concert of the Gustav Mahler Orchestra of Colombo, held on June 15, marked only my second time performing this masterpiece. (I personally do not know of other orchestral musicians around the world who would have experienced similar infrequent performances. This is one reason why I appreciate your feedback to my articles; they allow me to get a better reading of the global orchestral landscape.) The handful of orchestras currently operating in Sri Lanka having specific performance goals, and the irregularity of concerts is likely to have contributed to a lack of frequency. I must also note the tough economic circumstances with which most of our people are burdened, leading classical music aficionados to reconsider even the simple purchase of a concert ticket.
Nevertheless, playing Beethoven’s Fifth on a modern instrument (for the lack of period instruments) was a pleasant experience. The 12-year hiatus caused us to savor the work that much more. As much as it is difficult to replicate the timbre of the natural horn—the alternating open and stopped or partially stopped notes on the modern instrument in the manner Beethoven would have imagined—treading the tutti parts while not upsetting the overall balance of a Beethovenian orchestra proved to be a delicate operation. The initial horn call which transitions to the second theme of the first movement was fun to play but, giving some “oomph” to the opening statement of the second half of the movement was even more satisfying. The second movement was particularly enjoyable, especially playing the heroic theme with the trumpets, all the while restraining ourselves so as not to overplay the orchestra.
 |
|
(L-R) Jude Fernando and Vidhurinda Samaraweera, horns
|
My ever-loyal comrade on second horn did not let me down in the third movement where we led the orchestra to establish the faster tempo. I like to think that horns bring clarity during calamity in the third movement. The fourth movement is full of excitement, yet the pivotal role the horns play often goes unnoticed. The two fanfares which lead up to the presto, bolstering the piccolo, are both delicate and uplifting. To play alongside the fellow members of the brass section in the finale almost feels like the final fight scene in a Kung-Fu Panda movie!
The biggest challenge when performing Beethoven was the range Beethoven covered with the brass section. From the high-flying trumpets to the three-member trombone choir (featured in a symphony for the first time ever), covering the wide range was too much to ask since there was no alto trombone available on the island. Thus, the original alto trombone part was covered by a third horn player. Interestingly, there is a revised edition of the trombone parts to suit the modern orchestra where the alto trombone line is not notoriously high. The tenor and bass trombone parts were not different from the original and revised editions. The performance was, ultimately, a bringing together of new and old.
Why I focused on performing Beethoven’s Fifth is two-fold: first, to note some horn highlights in this under-appreciated work which are both glorious and subtly virtuosic; and second, to bring some perspective to readers of this Newsletter. I am aware that Horn and More is read by enthusiasts from different parts of the world. While we all accept that music is a universal language, we can also acknowledge that music-making is not the same for everyone. We live in different conditions depending on the part of the globe in which we live. Some of us have valuable resources—great teachers, vaster knowledge, cultural context, more orchestras, libraries, etc.—available, whereas in some communities, these can be hard-to-afford luxuries. In this beautiful month of July, I’d like to leave with you an important message: cherish your resources, regardless of how little you may think of them, and do not think twice to share with those in need.
 |
|
(L-R): Dharmasri Jayantha, Nuwan Gunawardhana, Prasanna Kumara, trombones;
Senira Prematillake, Jude Fernando, Vidhurinda Samaraweera, horns |
