I have played Holtons my entire horn playing life (40+ years). I have briefly tried Yamahas and Atkinsons. Yamahas did not work well for me and the Atkinson is about as close to the Holton quality that I've played. I know that the H179 is their most popular horn, but I have always preferred the H180. I have played a couple of Merker Matics and they are also excellent horns. Probably, the best Holton I've played was the Barry Tuckwell model, but that one is very expensive. There will be good and bad instruments from every maker out there. I never buy a horn that I can't try out first. In other words, I would never buy a hour that I couldn't turn down if I didn't like it. If at all possible, buy a horn from somewhere that has 2 pr 3 to choose from and buy the one that works best for you. If you can't find one you like at one place try another place. Don't ever settle for the best one available.
Good luck on your search.
